Resolution to Support Expansion of Emergency Planning Zones

SAFE Carolinas is working to get a resolution passed with Asheville City Council and Buncombe County Commissioners to support the expansion of emergency planning zones around nuclear power plants. If you are interested in passing a resolution in your town, please contact us. 


RESOLUTION TO SUPPORT EXPANSION OF EMERGENCY PLANNING ZONES AROUND NUCLEAR POWER REACTORS

Whereas current US Nuclear Regulatory Commission regulations establish a 10-mile Emergency Planning Zone for evacuations around US nuclear reactors and a 50-miles Ingestion Pathway Zone to monitor and potentially interdict contaminated food, water, milk and livestock;

Whereas the April 1986 nuclear accident  in Chernobyl and the March 2011 nuclear accident at Fukushima resulted in interdiction of contaminated food and livestock hundreds of miles from the reactor sites and Wales contaminated livestock approximately 1,000 miles away after the Chernobyl accident;

Whereas the real –world experience of the Fukushima and Chernobyl nuclear accidents resulted in evacuations of villages 25 miles away from Fukushima and over 100 miles away from Chernobyl, the 10 mile Emergency Planning Zone and 50 mile Ingestion Pathway zones are inadequate and outdated;

Whereas the proposed WS Lee nuclear station is directly 60 miles from Asheville, NC and proposed location on the Broad River in Gaffney, SC with headwaters above Lake Lure, Chimney Rock , North Carolina;

Whereas nuclear power is generally the most water intensive energy technology and 60 % of the continental US experienced drought conditions this summer (2012 ); the  proposed WS LEE nuclear station would use 47 million gallons of water a day from the Broad River to cool and operate the plant which already services the Cliffside Coal Plant 16 miles upstream using 20 million gallons of water per day;

Whereas a US and European scientific study published this year (2012) Source: “Nuclear, Coal Power Face Climate Change Risk: Study” by David Fogarty, revealed the likelihood of extreme drops in power generation at nuclear plants resulting in either complete or almost-total shutdowns are projected to triple and that most significant US impacts will be at power plants inland along major rivers in the Southeast;

Whereas the AP1000 Westinghouse reactor proposed for the WS LEE nuclear plant is under a court challenge for safety issues and design flaws exacerbating concerns for potential accidents;

Whereas the federal Price Anderson Act leaves the financial responsibility of a nuclear accident to the affected citizens and municipalities and whereas Asheville could experience threats to agriculture, decrease in tourism, radiation exposure leading to health consequences, environmental degradation, and an influx of evacuees from towns closer to the reactor site.

Whereas the citizens of Asheville deserve the greatest possible protection from nuclear power accidents and the greatest possible preparation to mitigate the effects of nuclear accidents;

Whereas current NRC emergency planning regulations are inadequate to provide a sufficient level of protection for the citizens of Asheville;

 BE IT RESOLVED THAT THE CITY OF ASHEVILLE

Supports the expansion of current Emergency Planning Zones from 10 to 25 miles around U.S.

Nuclear sites;

Supports the creation of a new Emergency Response Zone of 25 to 50 miles around US nuclear reactor sites that would require nuclear power utilities to identify evacuation routes and provide this information to the public within this zone;

Supports the expansion of the Ingestion Pathway Zone from 50 miles to 100 miles around US nuclear reactors sites;

Supports emergency evacuation exercises that practice response to situations involving regionally-appropriate initiating or concurrent natural disasters;

Supports the petition for Rulemaking submitted by 38 organizations across the United States on February 15, 2012, since endorsed by more than 2700 organizations and individuals, and docketed by the Nuclear Regulatory Commission as PRM-50-104.  In addition, the City of Asheville will inform the Secretary of the Nuclear Regulatory Commission and the appointed Nuclear Regulatory Commissioners of its support for PRM-50-104.

SAFE Carolinas

Asheville, NC

Contact:  Laura Sorensen  lsredoak@gmail.com

Requesting Rate Hike Hearing in Asheville

Progress Energy is requesting a 14% increase in electricity rates for residential customers.
SAFE Carolinas signed with Greenpeace and other environmental groups asking the NC Utilities Commission
to hold public hearings in Asheville and other strategic towns in NC.  It is important for the public to speak out concerning the rate hikes. We should have response as to the location by mid-November. We will be sure to keep you updated. 

The following is the letter that was sent to the NC Utilities Commission:

October 16, 2012

The Honorable Edward S. Finley, Jr.

North Carolina Utilities Commission

4325 Mail Service Center

Raleigh, NC 27699-4325

Re: Progress Energy Rate Hearings (Docket E-2 Sub 1023)

Re: Duke Energy Rate Hearings (Docket E-7 Sub 989) (anticipated)

Dear Chairman Finley:

We are writing you on behalf of the thousands of North Carolina members and Duke Energy ratepayers of our organizations interested in the upcoming Duke Energy rate hearings. Our members will be directly impacted by the outcome of the potential rate increases, as will all Duke Energy Carolinas and Progress Energy Carolinas customers throughout the state. In order to give customers of these utilities ample opportunity to testify and participate we have a few specific requests of the upcoming public hearing process:

1.       The upcoming public rate hike hearings are held in 9 locations across the state so as to allow geographic diversity for public input. We request that high density regions respective of each rate base have individual hearings to accommodate the thousands of concerned ratepayers in and around these municipalities. These should include Raleigh, Durham, Charlotte, Winston-Salem, Greensboro, Asheville, Pittsboro, Fayetteville, and Wilmington. 

2.       At the 2011 rate hike hearings, dozens of concerned residents were turned away because there was a lack of seating. To accommodate hundreds of people at each hearing, we request that each hearing space be large enough and overflow space made available should the crowd eclipse capacity.

3.       We request that hearings are translated into regionally important languages, especially Spanish. The Latino community is the largest growing in our state, and language access should not be a barrier to participation for any of our neighbors.

4.    Upon request, providing ASL interpreter services or other accommodation to make sure that all people have access to the proceedings regardless of any disability that they may have.

5.      Similar to how the high interest hearings from this summer were streamed live, we ask that all of the hearings are streamed live for concerned residents from across the state unable to attend in person.

6.   We request that all of the hearings be in the evening to provide opportunity for working people to attend and provide input. 

Thank for you taking the time to consider these requests. Hundreds of thousands of North Carolina families do not have a choice of their energy supplier. What we have is the opportunity to hold our utility accountable to our interests through proceedings like the upcoming rate hike hearings. 
As the agency charged with regulating rates throughout the state, we look to you to protect the interest of the public and ensure reasonable rates. To that end, ensuring equal and ample access for all North Carolinians is our goal.
The organizations signed believe collectively that taking these steps will give the hearings integrity they will lack otherwise. We look forward to hearing back from you by Friday, October 26, 2012, and will follow up as appropriate.
Sincerely,
SAFE Carolinas, Asheville, NC


This letter was also signed by:

350 Asheville

350 Boone

350 Winston-Salem

Action NC

Appalachian Voices

Canary Coalition

Catawba Riverkeeper® Foundation, Inc.

Clean Air Carolina

Clean Water for North Carolina

Democracy North Carolina

Disability Rights North Carolina

Dogwood Alliance

Environmentalists Inc.

Green Grannies

Greenpeace USA

Haw River Assembly

NC WARN

North Carolina Housing Coalition

North Carolina Interfaith Power and Light

North Carolina Justice Center

North Carolina League of Conservation Voters

Occupy Charlotte Environmental Working Group

Occupy Greensboro Energy Working Group

Proposition One Campaign

SAFE Carolinas

Southern Alliance for Clean Energy

Waterkeepers Carolina

We Love Mountain Island Lake

Western NC Alliance